Reviewer Guidelines

Reviewer Guidelines for NG Agriculture Insights
1. Purpose The purpose of the peer review process is to ensure the quality, relevance, and originality of the articles published in NG Agriculture Insights. Reviewers play a crucial role in maintaining the high standards of the journal and providing constructive feedback to authors.
2. Review Criteria When reviewing an article, please consider the following criteria:
  • Relevance: Is the article relevant to the journal's scope and of interest to its readership?
  • Originality: Does the article present new insights, ideas, or information?
  • Clarity: Is the article well-organized and clearly written? Is the content easy to understand for a broad audience?
  • Accuracy: Are the facts and information presented accurate? Are the sources reliable and properly cited?
  • Engagement: Does the article engage the reader and provide valuable information or insights?
3. Review Process
  • Acceptance: If you accept the invitation to review, please complete the review within the specified timeframe.
  • Confidentiality: Maintain the confidentiality of the review process. Do not share the article or your review with others.
  • Objectivity: Provide an objective and unbiased evaluation of the article.
  • Constructive Feedback: Offer specific suggestions for improvement, if applicable. Focus on the content and quality of the article rather than the author's background or affiliation.
4. Review Form Please use the provided review form to submit your evaluation. The form typically includes sections for:
  • Overall Assessment: Indicate whether you recommend acceptance, revision, or rejection of the article.
  • Comments to the Authors: Provide detailed feedback and suggestions for improvement.
  • Confidential Comments to the Editors: Share any additional comments or concerns that you do not wish to share with the authors.
5. Timeliness Please complete your review within the specified timeframe to ensure a timely publication process. If you anticipate any delays, please notify the editorial office as soon as possible.
6. Contact Information For any questions or concerns during the review process, please contact the editorial office at editorngai@ngenpub.com.
Thank you for your valuable contribution to NG Agriculture Insights. Your expertise and feedback are essential in maintaining the high quality of our journal.